After much frustration about two years ago I finally made the switch to 3-ring albums. I haven’t used a post bound album in a long time (since the first year of scrapping). I tried using the Pioneer strap conversion kits for post bound albums but didn’t have much success. I was using the Creative Memories strap albums which I really liked. But they are very expensive. That left me frustrated and searching.
Finally, I found a 3-ring album on clearance sale for $5. I thought, what the hey….and tried it (It was a Provo Craft that is no longer available, so I’m not going to review it).
After that, I was hooked!!
For today, I am reviewing albums made by seven manufacturers. I know there are additional ones now, but this is what I have. (I have purchased ALL these albums with my own money. There is absolutely no product /compensation involved here).
- We R Memory Keepers (WRMK)
- American Crafts
- American Crafts Premium
- Becky Higgins LLC
- Making Memories
- Doodlebug
- Pioneer
- Die Cuts With A View (DCWV)
So you can visualize the difference in the spine thickness, here is a couple pictures of them all together. (Yes, there are differing heights. I could only get them to stand together this way, but I do later address what I think are noteworthy height issues).

Left to Right: Pioneer, Doodlebug, We R Memory Keepers, Die Cuts with a View, American Crafts, Making Memories, Becky Higgins LLC
In the next picture you can see the size of the D-rings inside the albums.
I am going to begin reviewing with my least favorite first (thanks C for the help modeling and holding the ruler ;) ).
First up:
American Crafts. While I do like a great many of American Crafts products, this is one I am not going to buy again. This particular one is a naked cover chipboard. I bought it with the intention to add my own covering to it. But I was so unimpressed, I gave it to the kids and didn’t even bother.

Suggested Retail Price: $19.99
Yes, there are different covering options, this (the Modern) being the cheapest. However, I didn’t feel the fabric used for the covering of the more expensive ones was much of an improvement.
Pages fit in album: Honestly, I didn’t even try. I was so unhappy with it. But I would guess right about 20 page protectors using the thickness my pages are.
Overall Grade: D
One sentence: Yes it’s cheap, but I don’t believe it makes it a value because the quality is too far lacking. Slightly above the Modern Album from American Crafts is the American Crafts Premium Album. In my book, Premium is an exaggeration. I’m a big fan of American Crafts for many products, but sadly, albums is not one of them.
American Crafts Premium Album
I stepped up the price point on this album hoping to like it more than the Modern Album. Sadly, I was disappointed.
Suggested Retail: $24.99
This album is covered in a very light weight fabric. There is no coating on it to protect it from dirt or dirty hands. I also really don’t like that it’s the shortest height of all the albums (see first picture above). I don’t believe that the fabric of the covering will endure the test of time. Also, the inside of the album is just a paper, glued in place. I’m not convinced that quality of materials would hold up to the abuse albums receive in my house. I’m afraid the fabric or paper would tear at the joints and I’d have to replace it.
Additionally, there is no bookplate on the outside, a design feature I really like.
Pages fit in album: I fit about 23-25 page protectors in it.
Overall grade: C
One sentence: I believe that this album is a poor value for the price.
Next up:
Becky Higgins LLC (makers of Project Life, P365). I bought the album al a carte from the Project Life kit. I’m not sure it’s still available in this style, but I believe new ones will be coming. (I will be updating this with the new style made by WRMK when they come out)
Suggested Retail: $12.99 Amazon.com
This album has a padded paper covering with a cloth spine. The outside cover was fine, but what concerned me about longevity was the paper on the inside of the spine. I don’t feel like it will hold up to the test of use. (Update – I was quite surprised that the black tape is already coming off with the use it’s had – I’m anxiously awaiting the new albums to update this again).
There is also no book plate on the spine for easy labeling.
Pages fit in album: If using it for a scrapbook album rather than the Project Life purpose, I fit 23 page protectors in it.
Overall grade: C
One sentence: Better balance of price and quality, certainly not the best, but very fair for the price.
Pioneer Albums
Suggested Retail: $19.99
This particular album is a faux leather. They make several different coverings, however, I chose the faux leather. Colors selections are much more limited than other options. The spine is curved. However, the feel of the faux leather is a bit rough.
As you can see though, it is a much bigger ring. This album does have a “pocket” on the spine for labeling it as well as a photo slot on the cover. I think my favorite thing though is the corner protectors are round so they don’t damage my shelf.
Pages fit in album: 33 page protectors
Overall grade: B
One sentence: Definitely the best value. If you’re not super picky, this is a fantastic option (okay that was two)….
Die Cuts With A View (DCWV)
I think these albums are newer to the market, but I can’t be sure as I’ve had a hard time finding them at retail and online.


Suggested Retail: $19.99
If you’re looking for affordable, this is a great option, especially when you can purchase it on sale. I really like the slightly rounded corner protectors and the stitching.
The negatives to me were that the shades of colors weren’t exactly to my liking, and the faux leather felt cheap. The other negative is that the D-ring is slightly smaller. This album doesn’t hold quite as much.
The album is also a tad shorter (which might bother some if placing it next to a WRMK album). But the quality of assembly appears to be good.
Page Protectors Fit in Album: 20 to 23
Overall Grade: B
One Sentence: Great value, if you are flexible on color options, it’s might be perfect for you.
Making Memories

Suggested Retail: $24.99
This album is a linen covering. There are also faux leather covers (I have the faux leather in the post bound and do really like them). If you want a prettier, more decorated album, this one is great. I also really like the “oil rubbed bronze” finish of the bookplate on the spine.
Pages Fit in Album: About 23 for my pages
Overall Grade: B+
One Sentence: If you like pretty as your main priority, this is perfectly for you.
Doodlebug Designs
These are newer to the market, so I was anxiously waiting getting my hands on one! (But of course, I had to wait until I could get them on sale….)

The bookplate has a different shape, a bit more detail.

Suggested Retail: $29.99
This album has fun colors!! If you love the bright colors of Doodlebug Designs, this is definitely for you. In my opinion, they did the bright colors much better than WRMK did. But the flipside of that is I really don’t like the brown they offer. (That’s why I decided to go bright and do the aqua). This is the tallest of all that I am reviewing, so if you plan to mix it with existing WRMK albums and the 1/8” height difference will bother you, beware.
The inside is lined with another faux leather that feels very vinyl like. The texture of the faux leather though is better than others on the market, but not the best.
The other thing on this album that I can’t decide if is a plus or not is that the corners don’t have a metal corner protector on them. I really like that for the sake of my shelves (I’ve gouged my shelves quite a bit with the WRMK corners), however, I’m not sure how well the corners will handle the abuse of on and off the shelves as they are.
This album style is very classic and timeless, however I think the colors are very trendy. I'll let you decide what you think in that regard. But the quality will definitely last many many years, if not a lifetime.
Page Protectors Fit in Album: 25
Overall Grade: A- (the lack of more neutral colors as well as the feel of the leather keeps it from being higher).
One Sentence: Definitely a good quality album, and all the more perfect if you like bright playful colors.
Finally, let’s talk about
We R Memory Keepers. This is hands down my favorite.
Suggested Retail: $29.99 (the highest, however, I only buy when I can get then 40% off and stock up).
This album comes in many covers. There is a faux leather (a very good quality faux) and some different cloth options. I prefer the faux leather for the ability to clean it when grubby little hands look at it.
This album has both a book plate on the spine and corner protectors. The only negative I have about this album is the corner protectors have gouged my shelf up a little bit when I’m not especially careful putting it on the shelf.
This album also has a very classy, timeless and quality look to it. I also like the detail used on the inside as well.
As for the tactile touch of the faux leather albums, I like the feel of the WRMK the best by far.
Pages Fit in album: 25
Overall Grade: A
One Sentence: Definitely the album of choice for the picky or those who pride presentation and want an album to last a lifetime.

(this picture courtesy of a 6 year old photographer…LOL)….I also think the We R Memory Keepers hold the pages most securely and need the least bottom support of all albums reviewed. (however, the Pioneer held pretty securely too).
In Conclusion:
In conclusion, to find what album is best for you, you should first decide if your main priority is design or potential lifespan. If you are most worried about design, then purchase whatever tickles your fancy. If you are most worried about your pages being safe without having the replace the albums, I would look at the We R Memory Keepers or Doodlebug as your best option. The difference of the two being primarily which colors you like better. However, as I mentioned previously, if you are anal about albums together on a shelf, you will want to chose one brand and stick with it due to the varying heights. If you want durability but are on a tight budget, you may want to look at the Die Cuts With a View. But whatever you chose, make sure
you like it as well, because that’s what matter!
Thanks for reading!! If you have any questions, please e-mail me or comment and I’ll try to answer them.
(Note: The one album I have not yet reviewed is the Basic Grey. I have looked at in the stores, and honestly, I refuse to buy one unless I can buy it on sale. The D-ring is smaller and thus would hold less as well as I don’t like the paper covering. There is no bookplate, nor anything to protect the corners (of a paper covering). I’m afraid it wouldn’t last. The retail is $23.99)
Purchasing Albums: When purchasing albums, I always prefer to buy them onsale. I don't have a problem paying full retail for trendy supplies, but the basics, I really don't like to spend my scrappy budget on. I wait until I can find a good sale and buy several at a time. I
always prefer to purchase at my local stores first, however because that's not always an option (even if I'm willing to pay full price, they don't always stock what I like) I often order from
http://www.joann.com/ or
http://www.ritzcamera.com/ when they are 40% off.